• Property sold for: ₹5 Cr
• Purchased in FY 2015–16 for: ₹2 Cr
• Indexed Cost (CII based): ₹2.74 Cr
• LTCG:₹2.26 Cr
• LTCG Tax (@20.8%): ₹47.0 lakhs
• Net amount after tax: ₹5 Cr − ₹47L = ₹4.53 Cr (rounded to ₹4.6 Cr for simplicity)
SCENARIO A: Pay Capital Gains Tax & Invest ₹4.6 Cr in Mutual Funds
Future Value at different returns (8%, 10%, 12%) over 5 years
Note: LTCG on mutual fund gains above ₹1 lakh is taxed at 10% (excluding indexation).
SCENARIO B: Don’t Pay Capital Gains Tax — Reinvest Entire ₹5 Cr in a Property
(Section 54)
Let’s assume:
• Entire ₹5 Cr invested in residential real estate
• Growth rate: 6%, 8% and10% CAGR
• Holding period: 5 years
Summary Table
Note: All the returns are taken as post tax.
Property values include rental income if any +plus capital gain.
Conclusion: We believe that paying capital gains tax and investing the net proceeds in mutual funds offers a significantly better risk-reward profile than reinvesting in property purely for the purpose of saving tax.
Mutual funds provide key advantages like:
While real estate is illiquid and comes with operational and compliance burdens, mutual fund investments can be tracked daily and tailored to your risk profile. With a disciplined approach and a well-planned strategy, mutual funds are a superior choice — especially with a 5-year investment horizon. It also depends upon the age of the investor. This is not a one fit all solution.
In our view, if one can manage short-term emotional volatility and focus on long-term goals, mutual funds clearly emerge as the more efficient, flexible, and rewarding option.
Family Office | Estate Planning | Tax Services | ESOP Advisory | Company Incorporations | Mutual Funds | PMS | Bonds | AIF | Offshore Investing | Private Equity and Venture Capital Funds
Disclaimer: All the above views are for educational purposes and are not given as investment advice.
Sri Subhash is an astute banking and finance professional with 14 years of real-world experience in wealth management, advisory of financial instruments such as mutual funds-equity and debt-alternate investment funds ( AIF)-structure and offshore products-private equity-venture capital/debt-bonds and MLDs-priority banking-cash management-team management-and working with various cultures in various nations.
Plot No. 104, Usha's The Felicity, Fourth Floor, Road No. 2, Kakatiya Hills, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad, Telangana 500033
Copyright © 2025 VIKA WEALTH – All Rights Reserved.
Plot No. 104, Usha's The Felicity, Fourth Floor, Road No. 2, Kakatiya Hills, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad, Telangana 500033
Copyright © 2025 VIKA WEALTH – All Rights Reserved.